Forbidding a whole species should not be an option

Banning any fruit or vegetable is NOT an option

“Behold, I have given you every seed bearing herb, which is upon the surface of the entire earth, and every tree that has seed bearing fruit; it will be yours for food.”
[Beraishis 1/29]

I often wonder why our sages never banned any of the many species that Kashrut organizations claim are too “infested” with bugs to be permitted.

The thought came to me today that the answer is simple:

There is a well known rule in Halacha that although the Sages have the authority to forbid things that the Torah never forbade, in order to strengthen Torah law (Rabbinical transgressions) , they do NOT have the authority to forbid things which the Torah EXPLICITLY permits. [Taz Y.D. 117/3]

In the parsha this week, the Torah explicitly permits eating ALL species of fruit and vegetables!

So whereas checking commonly infested species before eating is required, banning an entire species is not an option.

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=581514328576452&set=a.494325060628713.1073741825.476148969112989&type=1&stream_ref=10

Let Kashrus Authorities not venture where even our Sages didn’t have the authority to go!

 

Shabbos with Rav Oppenheimer Shelita

Shabbat with Rabbi Oppenheimer in Buenos Aires!

A great highlight of our time in Buenos Aires was spending Shabbos Vayigash with the unofficial “Chief Rabbi of Argentina”, Rabbi Daniel Oppenheimer Shelita.

Head of a leading Torah school, Rov of the leading Ashkenazi community in the city, and the head of South America’s largest Kashrus Organization, Ajdut Kosher, this tzaddik of a man is also literally one walking Mussar Sefer who serves the food in his home himself with his wife, like Rabban Gamliel in the Mishna.

Everyone in town seems to know and love him, and he has time for everyone.
What man of this stature would come out at midnight to meet some strangers from South Africa at a local restaurant just to say hello and help us with Shabbos plans.

An oldstyle graduate of the Mir Yeshiva, this Talmid Chochom is really someone special!

Johannesburg Beth din relaxes strawberry checking rules

loaded from Feb 2014 via facebook page
Johannesburg Beth Din relaxes requirements for strawberry cleaning and checking, and permits use in establishments again!

In an email just sent out, the Kashrus department writes

“After extensive testing and the application of relevant halachic principles, the Beth Din has revised the checking/cleaning methods for strawberries.

There are three changes from the previous method. First, it is no longer necessary to sponge the strawberries down. Second, they need not be vigorously agitated in the water; just some light “swooshing” will suffice. Third, there is no need to cut them in half to look inside for worms.

The new method is as follows:

1. Cut off (don’t pull off!) the green leaf with about 1mm of the fruit.
2. Cut off any mushy parts as well as deep folds.
3. Soak the strawberries in very soapy water for 3 minutes.
4. After the soaking, the strawberries must be agitated in the water
5. Carefully wash the entire surface of each strawberry under a stream of cold water”

We commend Johannesburg on their open approach to halachic kashrut, and searching for the truth, whether it leads to stringency or leniency, and are sure that further research will reveal that many more of the extreme measures currently becoming “normal” in the world are totally unnecessary and against the Torah spirit of “Lachem Yiheye Leochla”

 

Hechshers on chocolates and camel’s milk

Camel milk in chocolates

Popular chocolate brands in south Africa recently lost their hechsher due to the local factories closing down and the products now being imported from the Middle East, where the Johannesburg Beth din is unable to supervise the products.

Whats the big deal? could ingredients really have changed?

well for one, not only is camels milk very common in that region, but chocolate is now being produced from it as well.

In the absence of any reliable supervision, one certainly cannot assume anything

 

Strawberries Survey March 2014- johannesburg

Johannesburg high quality strawberries still clean in summer!

a recent March Survey by Halachic Kashrus found Johannesburg “Woolworths” summer strawberries to be clean of bugs after vigorous washing

A followup to our winter survey last year was performed this March.

3 Mashgichim each checked 3 boxes of strawberries, 2 from woolworths, and 1 for Freshfellas, after vigorous washing under cold water.

Not one bug was found in any of the strawberries.

as samples came out clean after washing, there was no need to test them after soaping, which appears to be unnecessary based on this and last year’s sample.

This was admittedly a small sample, but based on two suppliers and 30 strawberries, and together with last year’s sample of 60 strawberries, we find it pretty convincing that strawberries bought from upmarket supplier Woolworths in Johannesburg can be presumed bug free after the tops are cut off and they are vigorously washed with water- without any soaking in soap!

this is not “psak halocho” but fact reporting, and shows that assumptions about insect infestations need to be regularly checked, and not just assumed to be accurate!

anyone with recent surveys that show precise conclusions to the contrary should please let us know urgently!

 

Bishul Akum and Fish- the Sushi element

Bishul Akum and Sushi quality Fish

There is no prohibition of Bishul Akum with foods that are normally eaten raw

High quality salmon, tuna, and other Fish is now commonly eaten raw by many as sushi and might now fit into this category

As many people still will not eat raw Fish at all, the above is still a grey area, but if your Help cooks your scottish salmon before you turn on the stove, dont forget to tell your Rabbi its sushi quality- it might just Help!

 

 

Why the big deal-Introduction

It is a biblical offense to eat “Sherotzim” (literally- creeping things)  , and one who intentionally eats one could transgress up to 5 different prohibitions.

sherotzim are a broad category that includes insects, worms, rodents and other species with short or no legs. These are divided into three main categories:

i. sheretz ha’of  (flying sherotzim), such as bees, flies, mosquitoes, hornets etc

ii. sheretz hamayim (water sherotzim), such as water-borne worms and insects, and water  mammals such as dolphins and seals

iii. sheretz ha’aretz  (land sherotzim), such as snakes, mice, all insects , etc

Not all sherotzim are actually forbidden by the Torah- insects and worms that grow in a fruit once it has been detached from the ground and have not yet left the fruit  are in fact permitted, and this distinction has relevance to later discussion on the subject.

As many types of produce tend to be infested with forbidden insects and worms, it is therefore sometimes  necessary to check such produce before eating it in order to avoid unintentionally consuming forbidden sherotzim.

 

There are 3 categories of such produce:

 

i. “Rov Muchzak betolaim”- If the majority of produce has been shown to be infested with halachically forbidden sherotzim  , it is generally agreed that there is a biblical prohibition to eat the produce before one has checked it, and that if one is unable to check  or clean the produce in a way that removes this majority of infestation, it is very hard to permit such produce. This will be the topic of a future post, Imyirtse Hashem.

 

ii. “Miut haMatzui”- If there is a significant minority of produce that is known to be infested with forbidden sherotzim, then although one a biblical level, one is permitted to follow the rule of “majority” and eat the produce without checking, there is a Rabbinic obligation to check the produce before eating if possible- where not possible, one may eat without checking. The definition of ” Miut haMatzui” will be the subject of a seperate post, but it is most commonly accepted to be 10% of portions eaten at one time.

iii. muchzak naki- if  less than a “miut hamatzui” is known to be infested, there is no need to check the produce at all before eating it and if one happens to unknowingly swallow a sheretz in the course of eating permitted produce, this is considered “misaseik”  [unintentional transgression] and one is not liable at all.

 

 

[based Y.D. 84]]

 

[ All Halacha blogs are summaries of my own learning and  subject to further self-editing  and user- correction- they are not psak halacha, unless specifically classified as such, and are for the purpose of study and discussion only]

DA taking a big risk by praising Mandela and Mbeki

In the excellent TV commercial recently censored by the South African Broadcasting Corporation, but now back on the air after the threat of court action,  the Democratic Alliance’s very eloquent candidate for Gauteng Premier, Mmusi Maimane, tell South Africa’s that the ANC of Jacob Zuma is not the same ANC of the great leaders that they voted for in the past.

for a party that used to attack these ‘great leaders”, one of whom, “Thabo Mbeki” was an HIV denialist and great supporter of Robert Mugabe, this is a rather hypocritical strategy.

One only hopes, that in contrast to the views expressed in the below article, the strong impact of the advert and message will at least help to woo some votes from those who have always loved the ANC but are now focused on Zuma’s crimes.

People, after all, have short memories.

http://www.bdlive.co.za/opinion/columnists/2014/03/24/the-democratic-alliance-makes-massive-strategic-zuma-blunder

 

American Neo Nazi terror attack in Kansas

The frightening attack on a Jewish centre in Kansas by a white supremacist American highlights once again that America’s race problems run far deeper than many like to admit.
contrary to sterotypes, it is not only black Americans who conduct violent crime, and not only muslims who practise terror.
More than enough mall shootings and terror attacks in recent American history have been carried out by deranged white males, whether racially or simple criminally or psychologically motivated.
Its time we realize that the enemy is not any one religious or racial group, but the extremists in each group that trade their humanity for cannibalism.
‘A raging anti-Semite’ – Who is Frazier Glenn Cross?
Cross, a former Green Beret, did two tours of duty in Vietnam, served time in prison, and launched unsuccessful bids to win public office.